Clubs • Frameworks
How Clubs Can Standardize Player Evaluation
A standard scoring model for clubs that want better recruiting consistency across departments and scouts.
February 27, 202610 min read
Why standardization wins
Without a shared evaluation model, decisions drift toward subjective arguments and status bias.
Suggested scorecard dimensions
Use weighted dimensions based on role and age context:
- Technical execution.
- Tactical decision quality.
- Physical readiness.
- Consistency and growth trajectory.
- Character, resilience, and coachability.
Process recommendation
Require written rationale for final decisions. This improves accountability and supports future calibration.
Quarterly calibration loop
Every quarter, compare scores against real outcomes and refine dimension weights.